Skip to content
Save $15 off Your next pharmacy order of $100+ with code: SAVERXMAY- Some Exclusions Apply
Save $15 off Your next pharmacy order of $100+ with code: SAVERXMAY- Some Exclusions Apply
Home Contact Dealer Login Free Shipping $75+

Cat Toys

Playing with cat toys can help keep your cat fit and active, both mentally and physically. Cat toys can help relieve stress, boredom, add physical exercise and help prevent behavioral problems

Filters
$
$
Mini Metro Balls, 3 pk - Jeffers - Dog Supplies > Dog Toys
Mini Metro Balls, 3 pk - Jeffers - Dog Supplies > Dog Toys
$4.99 - $4.99
$4.99
$4.99
$4.99 - $4.99
$4.99

Mini Metro Balls, 3 pk

Metro Paws

Mini Metro Balls, 3 pkMini Metro Balls® are smaller than a standard tennis ball they are perfect for smaller dogs and cats love them too. Unlike re...

View full details
Unicorn for Cats, 5', Assorted - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys Sold out
$3.99 - $3.99
$3.99
$3.99
$3.99 - $3.99
$3.99

Unicorn for Cats, 5", Assorted

Multipet International

Unicorn for Cats, AssortedUnicorns are cute, colorful, plush cat toys that contain catnip. Their curly, dangly tails and glitter spots will attrac...

View full details
Mouse Cat Toy, Gray -
Mouse Cat Toy, Gray - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys Sold out
$5.99
$5.99 - $5.99
$5.99
$3.50
$3.50 - $3.50
$3.50

Mouse Cat Toy, Gray

Ruff & Whiskers

Mouse Cat Toy, GrayThe Ruff & Whiskerz Wildlife Rodentz Mouse is the purrfect toy for your cat. Each Ruff & Whiskerz cat toy is filled with...

View full details
Cat Punch Ball Toy with Scratch Base Sold out
$12.49
$12.49 - $12.49
$12.49
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99

Cat Punch Ball Toy with Scratch Base

Duke's

Cat Punch Ball Toy with Scratch Base Give your frisky feline a space to play with this Cat Punch Ball Toy featuring a polka dot plush ball with col...

View full details
3 Striped Mice Cat Toys, 3pk Color Assorted
Sold out
$3.99
$3.99 - $3.99
$3.99
$1.99
$1.99 - $1.99
$1.99

3" Striped Mice Cat Toys, 3 pk

Duke's

3" Striped Mice Cat Toys, 3 pk Keep your cat entertained for hours with this 3 Pack of Striped Mice Cat Toys. Designed to stimulate your cat’s natu...

View full details
Rosie Rat Cat Toy, 6'L - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$7.09 - $7.09
$7.09
$7.09
$7.09 - $7.09
$7.09

Rosie Rat Cat Toy, 6"L

Boca Pet

Rosie Rat Cat Toy The Rosie Rat Cat Toy has a flat fuzzy body and soft suede leather head and tail. Your cat will be swiping and pouncing this "m...

View full details
Go! Cat Go! Play - N - Treat Twin Pack - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Go! Cat Go! Play - N - Treat Twin Pack - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$8.49 - $8.49
$8.49
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
$9.95

Go! Cat Go! Play-N-Treat Twin Pack

Go Cat Go

Go! Cat Go! Play-N-Treat® Twin Pack Go! Cat Go! Play-N-Treat® Twin Pack comes with 2 Treat Dispensing Balls that will reward kitty with treats whe...

View full details
Cool Cucumber Mad Cat Catnip Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Cool Cucumber Mad Cat Catnip Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$4.99 - $4.99
$4.99
$4.99
$4.99 - $4.99
$4.99

Cool Cucumber Mad Cat Catnip Toy

Mad Cat

Cool Cucumber Mad Cat Catnip Toy The Mad Cat Cool Cucumber will soon be your cat's new best friend! This soft and silly toy is filled with a unique...

View full details
Egg/Bacon Mad Cat Catnip Toys, 2 - pk - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Egg/Bacon Mad Cat Catnip Toys, 2 - pk - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$7.39 - $7.39
$7.39
$7.39
$7.39 - $7.39
$7.39

Egg/Bacon Mad Cat Catnip Toys, 2 pk

Mad Cat

Egg/Bacon Mad Cat Catnip Toys, 2 pk Brunch Buddies 2-pack is the perfect way to wake up from a cat nap! Adorable plush Egg & Bacon filled with ...

View full details
Fishing Rod 'N Reel Kitty Teaser Cat Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Fishing Rod 'N Reel Kitty Teaser Cat Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$8.79 - $8.79
$8.79
$8.79
$8.79 - $8.79
$8.79

Fishing Rod 'N Reel Kitty Teaser Cat Toy

SPOT

Fishing Rod 'N Reel Kitty Teaser Cat Toy Real casting action with clicking sound as you reel in your "catch". Features a replaceable feather "lure...

View full details
Furry Mice Cat Toy - 2' Furry Mouse Cat Toy, each
Furry Mice Cat Toy - 2' Furry Mice, box of 48
Sold out
$37.99 - $37.99
$37.99
$37.99
$37.99 - $37.99
$37.99

Furry Mice Cat Toys, 48 ct

Choo Choo/One Pet Planet

Furry Mice Cat Toys, 48 ct Keep your feline friend entertained for hours with these 2" Furry Mice Cat Toys. Perfect for encouraging your cat's natu...

View full details
Gone Fishin' Cat Teaser Wand Cat Toy, Assorted - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$7.69 - $7.69
$7.69
$7.69
$7.69 - $7.69
$7.69

Gone Fishin' Cat Teaser Wand Cat Toy, Assorted

SPOT

Gone Fishin' Cat Teaser Wand Cat Toy, Assorted Nothing fishy about this toy! Catch a fish with irresistible catnip and crinkle for tempting and tea...

View full details
SPOT Pet Laser Classic 5 - in - 1 - Jeffers - Dog Supplies > Dog Toys
SPOT Pet Laser Classic 5 - in - 1 - Jeffers - Dog Supplies > Dog Toys
Sold out
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99

SPOT Pet Laser Classic 5-in-1

Ethical Products Inc.

SPOT Pet Laser Classic 5-in-1 Formerly Spotbrites Laser Pet Toy Features 5 exciting laser images in one laser light. Watch as your pet chases th...

View full details
FroliCat Bolt Laser Cat Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
FroliCat Bolt Laser Cat Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$26.99
$26.99 - $26.99
$26.99
$21.99
$21.99 - $21.99
$21.99

FroliCat Bolt Laser Cat Toy

PetSafe

FroliCat Bolt Laser Cat Toy An interactive laser cat toy that provides hours of fun for you and your cat or dog. Simply hold the Bolt in your hand ...

View full details
SnugArooz Kitty Llamaste Crinkle Cat Toy with Catnip - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$4.99
$4.99 - $4.99
$4.99
$3.50
$3.50 - $3.50
$3.50

SnugArooz Kitty Llamaste Crinkle Cat Toy with Catnip

Snugarooz

Kitty Llamaste Catnip Crinkle Toy, 5"Introducing SnugArooz Cat toys! These fun and crinkly toys (with catnip) will bring endless hours of fun to yo...

View full details
Backyard Bird Cat Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Backyard Skunk Squeaky Cat Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$8.39 - $8.99
$8.39 - $8.99
$8.39
$7.95 - $8.95
$7.95 - $8.95
$7.95

Backyard Squeaky Cat Toys

Our Pets

Backyard Squeaky Cat Toys Bring the thrill of the hunt indoors with Backyard Squeaky Cat Toys, designed to keep your feline friend entertained, agi...

View full details
Refillable Sloth Silvervine Stick Cat Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Refillable Sloth Silvervine Stick Cat Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$5.99
$5.99 - $5.99
$5.99
$4.99
$4.99 - $4.99
$4.99

Refillable Sloth Silvervine Stick Cat Toy

Mad Cat

Refillable Sloth Silvervine Stick Cat ToyThe Refillable Sloth Silvervine Stick Cat Toy features a plush sloth with an enticing feathered tail hangi...

View full details
Sassy Sasquatch Cat Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sassy Sasquatch Cat Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$9.89
$9.89 - $9.89
$9.89
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99

Sassy Sasquatch Cat Toy

Mad Cat

Sassy Sasquatch Cat Toy Perfect for the cat who loves adventures, these adorable, silly catnip cat toys are sure to excite both you and your cat! T...

View full details
Platty Pup - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Platty Pup - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$8.01 - $8.01
$8.01
$8.01
$8.01 - $8.01
$8.01

Platty Pup

Our Pets

Platty PupInteractive Toys & Tunnels: The OurPets Backyard Collection Toys & Tunnelss encourage physical play and mental stimulation by app...

View full details
Catnip Crinkles Bumble Bee, 4.5' - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$3.99
$3.99 - $3.99
$3.99
$3.50
$3.50 - $3.50
$3.50

Catnip Crinkles Bumble Bee, 4.5"

Petsport

Catnip Crinkles Bumble Bee Cat Toy, 4.5"Catnip Crinkles Bumble Bee is a fun, catnip infused Bee shaped toy. It’s just the right size for cats to pl...

View full details
Fresh Veggies, 4', Assorted - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$4.99 - $4.99
$4.99
$4.99
$4.99 - $4.99
$4.99

Fresh Veggies, 4", Assorted

Petsport

Fresh Veggies, 4", AssortedFresh Veggies are premium, catnip infused, felted cat toys. High quality construction and natural fibers ensures healthy...

View full details
Yeowww! Crinkle Catnip Butterfly Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Yeowww! Crinkle Catnip Butterfly Toy - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
$0.00 - $13.99
$0.00
$5.00 - $13.99
$5.00 - $13.99
$5.00

Yeowww! Crinkle Catnip Butterfly Toy

Yeowww

Yeowww! Crinkle Catnip Butterfly ToyBright colors, crinkly wings, and 100% stuffed with pungent, organically grown catnip makes this the perfect t...

View full details
Tinsel Balls, each - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49

Tinsel Balls, Each

Boca Pet

Tinsel Balls Your cat will love to bat, fling, and toss these small, sparkly tinsel balls! A great cat toy for cats of all ages. Handmade in the ...

View full details
Triple Level Cat Toy Tower with Jingle Balls - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Triple Level Cat Toy Tower with Jingle Balls - Jeffers - Cat Supplies > Cat Toys
Sold out
$12.99 - $12.99
$12.99
$12.99
$12.99 - $12.99
$12.99

Triple Level Cat Toy Tower with Jingle Balls

Tiny's

Triple Level Cat Toy Tower with Jingle Balls Keep your cat engaged with this triple-level tower, complete with three jingle balls for interactiv...

View full details
Free Shipping

Most orders $75+

Give Us A Call

1-800-344-6337

Compare products

0 of 3 items selected

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare